Carl Schmitt and Francisco de Vitoria
The Paradox of Universalism in International Law
Sous la direction de José María Beneyto,  Ignacio de la Rasilla.
Brill avril 2026 Legal History Library Vol. 84 504 pages 186,74 €
9789004757417
Carl Schmitt and Francisco de Vitoria
Parution Droit international Histoire des idées 9789004757417 Brill

Présentation de l’éditeur

What could the critically labelled 'crown jurist of the Third Reich' and a 16th-century Dominican friar at Salamanca University—long revered as the founding father of international law during the age of discovery—possibly share? This pioneering multi-author volume is the first to examine the Vitoria–Schmitt nexus in the history and theory of international law, bringing together two classic thinkers whose radically different yet profoundly influential ideas continue to shape international law and political thought well into the 21st century.

Contributors are: Paolo Amorosa, André Azevedo Alves, Joseph W. Bendersky, José María Beneyto, Ignacio de la Rasilla, Lauren Benton, Leonor Durão Barroso, Maximiliano Hernández Marcos, Ryan Martinez Mitchell, David Pan, Daniel R. Quiroga-Villamarín, Juan Pablo Scarfi, Ville Suurone, Christopher Rossi, David Roth-Isigkeit, Johannes Thumfart, Jochen Von Bernstorff, Valentina Vadi, and Miguel Vatter.

 

Sommaire

Chapter 1 Introduction: The Vitoria–Schmitt Nexus in the History and Theory of International Law
Authors: José María Beneyto and Ignacio de la Rasilla

Part 1 The Reception of Vitoria and Schmitt in International Legal Thought
Authors: José María Beneyto and Ignacio de la Rasilla

Chapter 2 Vitoria and Schmitt: Revisiting Political Theology and the Concept of Grossraum in the Twenty-First Century
Author: José María Beneyto

Chapter 3 Carl Schmitt on Imperialism and International Law
Author: Jochen von Bernstorff

Chapter 4 The Problem of Limited War: Vitoria and Schmitt on Imperial Violence
Author: Lauren Benton

Chapter 5 The Founding Father of Imagination: Habermas and Koskenniemi on Vitoria
Author: David Roth-Isigkeit

Part 2 Conceptual Crossroads in International Law and Political Thought
Authors: José María Beneyto and Ignacio de la Rasilla

Chapter 6 Planetary Enmity, Global Community and International Law: The Case of Vitoria and the Spanish Conquista
Author: Miguel Vatter

Chapter 7 Sovereignty and International Law from Vitoria to Schmitt
Author: David Pan

Chapter 8 Vitoria on International Law and the Schmittian Critique of the Liberal Order
Authors: Leonor Durão Barroso and André Azevedo Alves

Part 3 Discovery, Nomos, and Conceptions of Space
Authors: José María Beneyto and Ignacio de la Rasilla

Chapter 9 The Spatial Imagination of International Law in China
Author: Ryan Martínez Mitchell

Chapter 10 The Monroe Doctrine and the Influence of Vitoria and Carl Schmitt in Latin America
Author: Juan Pablo Scarfi

Chapter 11 Beyond Discovery: Decolonizing International Law through Long-Term Historical Analysis
Author: Valentina Vadi

Chapter 12 The Extravagant Pretension: Schmitt, Vitoria, the Discovery Doctrine, and the Trail of Tears
Author: Christopher R. Rossi

Part 4 Historical and Contemporary Pathways to Vitoria and Carl Schmitt
Authors: José María Beneyto and Ignacio de la Rasilla

Chapter 13 Tyrannum licet deciper: ‘The mind has its ineluctable freedom…even in the claws of the Leviathan’
Vitoria as Clue to Schmitt’s Concepts of Grossraum, Race, and War during World War II
Author: Joseph W. Bendersky

Chapter 14 ‘An Appropriate Alliance’: Situating the Laws of Friendship in Vitoria, Schmitt, and the History of International Legal Thought
Author: Daniel R. Quiroga-Villamarín

Chapter 15 Displacing Vitoria? Carl Schmitt on Emer de Vattel in the History of Modern Ius Gentiums
Author: Maximiliano Hernández Marcos

Chapter 16 Schmitt vs. Vitoria on the Digital Battlefield: Free Flow of Information, Digital Sovereignty, and the Neutrality of Technology
Author: Johannes Thumfart

Part 5 Vitoria and Schmitt in the Canon of International Law
Authors: José María Beneyto and Ignacio de la Rasilla

Chapter 17 ‘Ancora tu?’ Questioning Carl Schmitt’s Place in the Canon of International Law
Authors: Paolo Amorosa and Ville Suuronen

Chapter 18 Carl Schmitt and Francisco de Vitoria: Classics of International Law?
Author: Ignacio de la Rasilla